How the Pain Pleasure Principle can Cause Procrastination
If you’re working towards a goal or outcome that you want, a lot of times you are going to find resistance. In a perfect world, we would all set goals and achieve them with ease, but usually resistance increases the closer we reach our goal, depending on how difficult, scary or painful you perceive that task to be. Sometimes even just the thought of completing certain tasks can make you want to disappear like that Homer Simpson meme where he fades into the bushes.
Unfortunately, it’s human nature to seek pleasure and avoid pain, so you can’t avoid it. However, you can overcome it if you recognize when it shows up in your life and shift your perspective around the situation. Being able to ask the right questions will allow you to stop viewing change as painful, or uncomfortable, and view them as more comforting and pleasurable instead. If you need help, then keep reading to learn 4 questions to ask yourself to help you overcome procrastination and start making moves.
how the Pain Pleasure Principle Affects our personalities...
In order for me to properly explain the pain pleasure principle, I must first explain the three structures of our personality, as told by Sigmund Freud (who is the founder of the pain pleasure principle). Freud used an iceberg analogy to explain how human’s personalities are constructed into three separate parts:
- The superego is reflected in what we often call our conscience and evaluates the morality of our behavior (sometimes harshly). It houses our conscious thoughts and deems things as either right, wrong, good or bad. Keep in mind that the superego doesn’t consider reality, it only consider’s whether our deepest urges or impulses can be satisfied in acceptable moral terms.
- Now the ego, is the preconscious (or subconscious) part of our personality that is developed during early childhood. It is at this age where we learn about the constraints of reality. Examples include learning not to kick other kids on the playground when they make you angry or learning how to use the toilet instead of wearing a diaper so you can go whenever you want. According to Freud, the ego follows the reality principle, meaning that it tries to bring individual pleasure within the norms of society. The ego also helps us to test reality so we can see how far we can go without getting into trouble and hurting ourselves. Whereas the id is completely unconscious, the ego is partially conscious and houses our higher mental functions including: reasoning, problem solving and decision making.
- Lastly, the id (our unconscious mind), (Latin for “it”) is home to our unconscious desires and is a pool of amoral and often vile urges that are craving to be expressed. In Freud’s view, the id has no contact with reality and works according to the pleasure principle, meaning that it is always seeking pleasure and can become addicted to seeking immediate gratification if not kept in check.
Now the ego acts as mediator and tries to find balance between meeting the demands of the id, the superego as well as the real world. For example your ego might say, “I will have sex only in a committed relationship and always practice safe sex.” Your id however, screams, “Sex! Now!” and you superego commands, “Sex? Don’t even think about it.”
The Pain Pleasure Principle Explained…
So… the pain pleasure principle basically states that everything action we take in life is because we’re either avoiding pain or moving toward pleasure. If you’re continuing a habit or behavior that you don’t like, it’s because you’re linking more pain to stopping habit, than you are to continuing it. Such as individuals who continue to smoke despite knowing all of the unhealthy side effects.
On the other hand, if there’s something you’re not doing that you want to do, it’s because you link more pain to doing it than not doing it. For instance, you may want to start exercising to get in shape, but the pain of engaging in uncomfortable workouts every week is greater than the discomfort of staying in your current state of health.
Although we may deny this and make excuses as to why we are procrastinating or why you don’t really want to change, the truth is that you KNOW that making the change will pay off and be much more beneficial than staying stuck in old patterns.
Titaniumsuccess.com explains that there are 6 rules to understanding the pain pleasure principle which include:
All Decisions Made by Human Beings are to Avoid Pain or Gain Pleasure. I mean think about it. Why do you brush your teeth? Why would a woman spend precious time applying makeup before going out? Why would someone go to the gym every day? All of these actions can be sliced down to an individual trying to attain pleasure and/or avoid the pain that an action is going to bring. It’s all pain and pleasure.
People Will do Much More to Avoid Pain than they Will to Gain Pleasure. Studies have demonstrated time and time again that people will do much more to avoid short term pain than they will to gain short term pleasure. For example, an individual would rather stay complacent in a dead end job instead of endure the discomfort of starting over at a new company. As you can see, avoiding a certain amount of immediate pain wins over gaining immediate pleasure every time.
Perception IS Reality. It’s the perception of pain and pleasure, not actual pain and pleasure that drives people. Since we don’t really ever know for sure what the future will hold, our preconscious brain, specifically the prefrontal cortex within the frontal lobe of our brain, is constantly making assumptions and judgements about the future. It’s this perception of future pain and pleasure that drives our actions. Unfortunately, it turns out that our perceptions are often very flawed, especially when it comes to things that are a bit more complex than running away from a predator or falling from heights.
Pain and Pleasure are Modulated by Time. Not only are we trying to avoid what we perceive to be painful and get what we perceive to be pleasurable, but timing also matters. The closer something is to this moment, the more pain or pleasure we attach to it. Therefore, pain tomorrow is not as powerful of a force as pain today. Pain in a decade is absolutely far less motivating (or demotivating) that pain a week from now. This is precisely why most human beings have such a hard time saving money even though you can receive interest and free money by delaying spending, or why some individuals struggle to remain consistent with healthy eating and lifestyle habits in order to avoid developing chronic health conditions in the long term.
As time goes on, our perception of pain and pleasure changes. Every decision you make results in at least one or more of the following: short term pain, long term pain, short term pleasure or long term pleasure. Short term always wins over long term unless there is a substantial amount of pain or pleasure associated with the long term avoidance of pain or gain of pleasure involved. Pain, or the level of perceived pleasure decreases with time.
- Emotions always beat logic when thinking of the pain pleasure principle. When thinking of making a decision based on gaining pleasure or avoiding pain, there is also an emotional aspect to the decision as well as a logical or more intellectual aspect to it. How many times have you looked at some ice cream sitting in front of you and had the ice cream even though you knew intellectually that you should not have the ice cream? We have all been there. Logically, you shouldn’t have the ice cream but emotionally, you want the ice cream. What wins? Intellect or emotions?
An ounce of emotion wins over an ounce or two of logic every time. The pain or pleasure related to our emotions are hard-wired in our brains to be much stronger because it’s the primitive part of our brain that tells us to act rather than think ahead to the future.
- Survival vs Desire in the Pain Pleasure Principle. Finally, anytime our survival response is triggered, everything else essentially shuts down. This concept can be explained by thinking that pain and pleasure can be further broken down into things that are hard-wired for survival and things that are mere wants. It’s easy then, to understand, that if something triggers a survival response, such as running away from a predator, it is going to override just about every other desire in that moment. When most people hear this principle, however they assume that the survival instinct is naturally going to be the one that is trying to avoid pain but that isn’t necessarily the case.
The desire to consume sugar or other addictive foods is the perfect example of something that is absolutely hard-wired. If you love cookies and someone puts a cookie in front of you, you are instinctually driven to eat the cookie. Now, many times, we are able to use enough logic and future pain to stop ourselves but over 50% of the US population loses that battle several times per day! You are hard wired to eat sugar to stay alive and while processed foods are only 100 years old, our genetics are over 100,000 years old! From a survival perspective, the more calories, the better. Your brain thinks eating the cookie means survival and not eating it means death!
Now that you know a little bit more about the pain pleasure principle and how complex it can be, let’s take a look at how it causes resistance and procrastination in our lives.
How the Pain Pleasure Principle Causes us to Procrastinate
Many of us remain stuck on autopilot when it comes to managing the demands of day to day living that we may not realize when our habits, relationships or mindset is negatively affecting our lives. So much of the time we are working in the conscious realm, without really being aware of it. This is because when repeated over time, these habits rewire our subconscious to accept these faulty programming which can make it difficult to break free from the cycle.
So time progresses, our days usually look similar, we know how to plan, what to generally expect from a day, how our lives will likely progress… Until something comes and throws our routine off balance in a major way. These ‘shake-ups’ can cause discomfort, instability, fear or worry and sometimes pushes us to question ‘what else is there’.
The best way to overcome this pain pleasure principle is to first be aware of how it shows up in your life. Although there are many ways that resistance shows up in our lives (which I explain in a separate blog post). Mentally, it can show up a few ways including:
- Excuses as to why we should not make changes. For instance, if it is time to take your car to the auto shop to get it fixed but you are afraid of knowing the price, or the extent of the damages, we may create excuses as to why we don’t need to go to the dealership or find short term solutions to fix the problem such as putting duct tape on the bumper to keep it functioning.
- Feelings of anger or frustration can also be another way that the pain pleasure principle creates resistance in our lives. We may feel angry or frustrated at the mere thought of making changes in our lives which can make us stubborn and have us revert back to the comfort of our old habits to feel safe again.
- Being impatient is another form of mental resistance. It is a resistance to learning and changing by demanding that the changes or transformation must be done right now. A good example of this would be how individuals depend on medication to alleviate symptoms of chronic lifestyle conditions (such as high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes etc) instead of making the dietary and lifestyle changes necessary to resolve the conditions completely.
- Fearful thoughts that cause us to worry about the future can also have us clinging to the comfort of the past instead of facing the uncertainty in the new. The thoughts that are often in our minds are concerned with the fears and pressures of life. Things like “What will happen if I lose my job? I wonder if my partner might be unhappy with our relationship. What if I don’t have enough money when I retire?” These may be based on reality but if we examine them, many may in fact be considered
irrational fears. Regardless, they grab our own constant attention and have us link more pleasure to sticking with our current habits which causes us to continue to procrastinate making positive changes.
Physically, when the pain pleasure principle is causing you to procrastinate making changes, you may feel your body become tense, stiff or as though you are fighting against resistance. From personal experience, I have encountered moments where symptoms of ADHD arise and although I may manage to start the task I’m procrastinating on, I find difficulty completing the task.
For instance, I could be physically pushing through the resistance to wash the dishes and as I start to unload the dish washer, I notice that I’m low on wash cloths and as a result, I find myself starting a load of laundry instead. There are many other ways that the pain pleasure principle can create resistance in our lives, and I explain them in another blog, but for now, let’s learn a simple way to combat our instinctual nature to seek pleasure and avoid pain.
How to Overcome the Pain Pleasure Principle to Take Action
Regardless of how the pain pleasure principle creates resistance in your life, using mindfulness techniques can help you become aware of how you procrastinate or resist making forward progress towards your goals. Being mindful or practicing meditation can:
- Increase our positive emotions and decrease negative ones
- Improve our cognitive function and our ability to focus
- Strengthen our problem solving abilities
- Enhance mental resiliency
- Bring about actual pathological changes in the brain and thereby affect learning, memory, emotional regulation and empathy.
- Lessen physical and emotional pain
- Improve overall health
- As well as mend relationships
Too often people’s reaction to mindfulness is that it’s silly or that it doesn’t make sense. Unless you are used to it, practicing mindfulness can be a difficult to master, especially if you are struggle with chronic stress, anxiety or other chronic mental health conditions.
When it comes to learning mindfulness, the daily practice is perhaps the most important component. Just as you wouldn’t expect to learn to surf by reading a book about surfboards and waves, learning mindfulness practice is no different than any other skill that involves both mind and body.
Practicing mindfulness is like building up a muscle, the more you exercise it, the stronger it becomes. Only rather than building up a muscle, practicing mindfulness strengthens our mind. Asking these 4 questions can help you motivate yourself to take action and make positive changes in any area of your life.
4 Questions To Ask yourself that uses the Pain Pleasure Principle to Motivate Change...
Now, the following questions will help you stop unwanted patterns and make needed changes by associating massive pain with keeping around the OLD pattern and massive pleasure with making the desired change.
Before I list out these four questions, take time to think about the habit or behavior you need to change to reach your goals/dreams along with the new habit, or outcome, you desire. Get a good mental picture of how those two habits compare to one another. If these two habits or behaviors have any emotions associated with them, try to put a label on them such as anxiety, fear, comfort, peace etc. A good idea to help with this activity would be for you to write them down on a piece of paper or in a journal along with these four questions:
- What is the PAIN you associate with stopping the old habit or behavior? Or to put it another way, what is the PAIN you expect if you make this change? This can be pain from the experience of making the change and/or the pain you would experience if you DID reach your goal?
- What is the PLEASURE you’ve gotten from releasing this old habit or behavior? What benefit do you receive from keeping this old pattern or problem in your life?
- What is the PAIN that will happen if you DO NOT stop the habit or behavior? How will it impact your life, your career, your family?
- What is the PLEASURE you will experience when do make this change and reach your goals and dreams? How will your life be better? How will you feel? What weight will be lifted? What other important outcomes will come from this?
Remember not to rush the answers to these questions. Take some time to really brainstorm and go deep because you may realize that you are hiding some subconscious limiting beliefs behind these habits which is why you are finding it difficult to make an easy transition from one habit or behavior to another.
I understand breaking through limiting beliefs to make big positive changes in your life can be difficult, especially is you struggle with chronic stress or anxiety but it doesn’t have to be. Below are 4 great tips to help you remain consistent on your behavior change journey:
- It’s simple, but not easy
- Remember your practice is not a performance
- You will be imperfect at it at first (we all are)… And that’s okay!
- Keep acknowledging your effort because that is what matters
If you think of the hardest thing for you to do and how much you procrastinate completing it, then you are in fact, looking at your greatest lesson at the moment. Surrendering, giving up the resistance, and allowing yourself to learn what you need to learn, will make the next step even easier. Don’t let your resistance keep you the making the changes necessary to live a healthier, happier life.
My free Stress Alchemy masterclass can teach you how to balance your mind, body and spirit in order to reduce chronic stress or anxiety while improving your health and life in the process. If you’re interested to learn more about it, then sign up below to have it sent to your inbox. I hope this helps!
In Good Health,
Amber Stewart BS,
Holistic Nutritionist
Certified Master Life Coach
CTNC Mental Health Specialist
Hi! My name is Amber and I’m a Body Goals Builder, Master Life Coach, Certified Health Coach, CTNC Mental Health Specialist, Stress Alchemist & Fear Conqueror
I used to be a people pleasing, work-a-holic who stressed herself out to climb the wellness industry’s corporate ladder, while obsessing over her self image. I soon realized that none of it mattered if I wasn’t happy with myself, inside and out, and surrounded around people who loved and respected me.
I now help individuals who are stressed out, out of shape and struggling to find balance in their lives learn how to ease their worries, improve their health, create 10x more joy in their lives and manifest the life of their dreams. At the STEW Project, we are maximizing our living potential by Simply Taking an Emphasis on Wellness.